Friday, June 10, 2011

Huh? So what? and Oh yeah?

I previously mentioned the three things Orson Scott Card said are going through a reader’s mind. That is, Huh?, So what? and Oh yeah?. Here is a breakdown of what it means. (I copied the base idea of these three into a notepad a long time back from someone’s notes to an OSC bootcamp. Can’t remember who.)

“Huh?”
What it means
The reader is lost. Something doesn’t make sense. The reader is confused as to what is happening. It might be something that wasn’t explained sufficiently. This can often happen if you assume a reader would know what something means when they do, in fact, not.

How to fix it
You need to give the story clarity. Make sure you’re not assuming prior knowledge from a reader that might not be there. A good way to test this is through beta readers who know nothing about what you wrote. If you find such a problem, you need to make things clear or fix any inconsistencies. Look out for parts where you imply to a high degree – it might be a place where you could lose a reader.

“So what?”
What it means
The reader doesn’t care. A man is being chased by a rabid dog, but the reader doesn’t care whether the man gets bitten or not. It’s all the same to him/her. You need a reader to sit on the edge of their sitting surface and gnash their teeth, anxiously awaiting the result of the chase.

How to fix it
You need to let the reader care. Mostly, such a situation calls for character development. You need to show the reader that the person in a pickle (or anything else, really) is worth caring about. You need to tell them why they should care. The hero is a good guy. The woman is the key to saving the world. Whatever the case may be. This is the reason why people tell you not to start a story with danger. An unknown character in a dangerous situation will immediately put the reader on a So what course. You have some gap from the start of the story, but it’s still tricky. Give the readers some context so that they know why they should care.

“Oh yeah?”
What it means
The reader doesn’t believe what you’re saying. Now while all fiction has a degree of that – it is fiction after all – the key is to, as they say, suspend disbelief. The more real everything sounds, the more they will believe what the author is saying.

How to fix it
The reader has to have faith in what you’re saying. Now there is a lot of advice out there on how to suspend disbelief, but I’ll touch the subject lightly. Using coincidences to resolve conflict is a bad idea. You can use them to initiate conflict, but never to resolve them. Having characters act out of character is another one. Stay true to the characters rather than the plot. If something seems hard to swallow, don’t leave it. Put something in earlier to make it more believable (e.g. putting a gun in the description of the mantelpiece in the first chapter so that you can use it to kill the villain in the final one) or change your plot to be more believable.


These three questions should be kept in mind especially when revising. Getting a beta reader to point them out would be useful. OSC himself said that any rule can be broken, so obviously, none of these are necessarily indicators of problems. It’s just useful if you wonder where the fault lies.

Wednesday, June 8, 2011

Push your Limits

If there’s one thing I’ve come to realise, it’s that mistakes breed success. Justine Musk made a post about it not long ago. But that’s not what I want to say here.

When you practise something (with the intention of getting better at it) repetition is usually the key. If you repeat the thing enough, you get better. But that’s not entirely true. In order to grow, you need to push yourself. Challenge your limits. Much like strength training, if you repeat what you already do easily, you won’t get better. You need to push your limit and challenge your ability.

When it comes to writing, finding a limit is pretty hard. Writing is writing, right? But perhaps there is more to it than that. Look at your own writing, and chances are, you’ll see something that is less than you want it to be. Say, you don’t do well with a strong plot line. In other words, you’ve become reliant on other elements to keep your story upright.

Every writer can work on that which makes him or her struggle. If your plots are generally weak, try writing a story in which your plot carries your story. Don’t let go of the other elements, but push yourself to make the weaker part stronger.

Maybe it’s not so easy to identify a weakness, or maybe there isn’t a specific problem. In that case, the key lies in boundaries. Limits. Say, giving yourself a time limit to finish a project. This works best if someone else is calling the shots (especially if you’ve already taken money from them and need to deliver). The pressure might be pretty high, but in that environment, your ideas might just flow better (or maybe it just forces you to finish the story even though you don’t like it).

Challenge your abilities. That’s the only way to make them better. Do something your not used to and practise it. Each word you write will send you a step closer to achieving whatever writing goal you’re aiming at.

--

In other news, remember that Stories for Sendai comes out the 30th of June. Buy a copy to read stories and poems from awesome writers (and one from me) and help Japan in the process.

Monday, June 6, 2011

Crafting a Story : Catalyst

The catalyst’s random word is:




A catastrophe is an event that results in, or a state of, great misfortune or ruin. What the catalyst should be is the event or state that allowed Irwin’s ghost to come back from wherever it was.

Something, somewhere, went wrong. For the best results, I think it would be a good idea that the event was caused by either Henry (who I’m going to have to give a new surname, since I recently found out that Henry James is a famous person) or Jasmine. Maybe a séance with Irwin’s spirit gone wrong. All things considered, Henry doesn’t seem to be the type of person who would have anything to do with spirit communication (or belief in them for that matter). Therefore, it will have to fall to Jasmine to do that. I didn’t want her to have another secret and Henry with still nothing, but I’d rather stay true to the characters.

Okay, Jasmine is still a relatively unexplored character, so we can juggle traits around quite a bit. Let’s say that she is a very superstitious. So she carries a hare’s foot with her for luck, will freak out if she breaks a mirror, that kind of thing. So, in her guilt over Irwin’s death, Jasmine goes to a medium to speak to his spirit (this is shortly before Henry decides to ask her with him to the cabin/house in the forest). By speaking to his spirit, they awaken Irwin and allow him to see what is going on. He gets angry because he’s dead and maybe breaks apart the medium’s house or maybe even kills her. Because he’s awake, he sees how Henry “steals” his girl, therefore making him mad and enabling him to pull a poltergeist on Henry and Jasmine.

I’m going to assume Irwin has limited control at first, but at later stages gains full traditional poltergeist powers – perhaps with a twist or two. This includes moving objects around and making noises (such as a knocking or scraping), generally with the intention of scaring people. But Irwin is really angry, so he must have some way to really put these people in danger. I also want him to be able to tell Henry who he is and why he wants to hurt him, therefore revealing Jasmine’s secret. Thus, Irwin must communicate. This can either be along the lines of him being able to take on a pseudo-physical form or writing on the walls. But the writing seems kind of un-Irwin. Irwin is furious. He’s dead. Why would he waste time writing on walls? Unless it is in the early stages when he can’t do much. However, then Jasmine’s secret will be out too soon.

Ergo, I think I’ll give Irwin a physical form of some kind. Maybe a bunch of objects held together with his powers that allows him to talk (maybe through the manipulation of an electronic speaker). He tries to create himself again, because he doesn’t want to be dead.

To make him dangerous, I think we’ll give him serious telekinetic power. Throwing of knives, tables, etc. The details can come in later.

That was all the components that are necessary for a story (as far as I can tell at the moment). All that remains now is to bring the pieces together, flesh out the characters and figure out how it’s going to end. Then we’ll have a rough framework. Then we figure out a theme, and then the story can be written.

Next week, I’ll list all the things necessary for the bringing together of parts and then do each of those in subsequent weeks.